Boardroom Forum invitations open this summer
IRC Incident Response Consortium Est. 2017 Join the community
Home/Resources/Breach Budget Game
An IRC original since 2015, rebuilt for the relaunch

Can you budget your way through a breach?

You have one million dollars and five NIST functions to spread it across. Make your choices, then face a randomly drawn incident and see whether your budget holds the line.

Your budget

$1,000,000 to allocate.

Remaining
$1,000,000

Identify

Know what you are defending. Asset inventory, risk assessment, threat intelligence, knowing where the crown jewels live and who can touch them.

$0
0%

Protect

Keep the attackers out. Access control, hardening, patching, awareness training, email security, the everyday controls that stop most attacks before they start.

$0
0%

Detect

Spot the one that gets through. Monitoring, SIEM, endpoint detection, alerting, and the people who triage what the tools surface.

$0
0%

Respond

Act when it happens. The IR plan, the playbooks, the retainer, the practised team that contains an incident before it becomes a headline.

$0
0%

Recover

Get back to business. Backups that restore, continuity plans that work, and the communications that rebuild trust afterwards.

$0
0%
How others spend

A typical shape, for comparison.

An illustrative mid-market allocation. Protect and Detect usually take the biggest share; Respond is where underspend hurts most on the day.

Protect
30%
Detect
25%
Respond
20%
Identify
15%
Recover
10%
Budget tips

Five rules the game rewards.

Balance beats brilliance

A million dollars of detection with no response capability just means watching the breach in high definition. The game punishes lopsided budgets, and so do real incidents.

Spend the budget

Unspent security budget is not prudence, it is unmanaged risk. Money left on the table counts against you when the incident lands.

Respond is the multiplier

Every scenario goes better when a practised team with a plan takes over in the first hour. It is the cheapest function to underfund and the most expensive to have missing.

You cannot protect what you have not identified

Skimp on Identify and the other four functions defend the wrong things. Asset inventory is boring until the day it is everything.

Recovery is part of the fight

Backups that restore and communications that hold trust turn a bad week into a footnote. Zero on Recover turns a footnote into a quarter.

Different threats, different shapes

Ransomware leans on Protect and Recover; an insider leans on Identify and Detect. Run the game a few times: the scenario is drawn at random.